Two big billies

[oregonhunting]

Which goat scores better?

 

[oregonhunting]

Goat 1

Goat 1

 

[oregonhunting]

Goat 2

Goat 2

 

[oregonhunting]

Same

Goat

 

[jimss]

Nice goats! They almost look like the same goat to me. About 80% of a goat's score is MASS! It's a little tough to tell the difference in mass in the photos.

 

[LopeHunter]

Looks like less gap between horns on Goat 1. Might be a sign of better bases.

 

[redwoood]

I have 0 experience but I'd say goat 1. Appears to be heavier. Body looks huge too.

 

[oregonhunting]

Thats what I was thinking, goat 1 is heavier. Goat 2 looked longer but not by much. Both awesome goats. A good tough decision to have!

 

[Topgun 30-06]

This may help to make a better guess. I'm going to have to go with #2, as I think he carries better mass all the way to the tips.

 

[oregonhunting]

Goat 1

Goat 1 again.

Thanks for your opinions. Hunt starts the 1st. Getting close!

 

[npaden]

Really a toss up for me. Goat 2 is longer, but Goat 1 has more mass at the bottom. Both look to be smoker goat though, pretty hard to go wrong with either one.

Good luck!

 

[Graves14]

The one you shoot!!!!

 

[St52v]

Looking at that last pic I think he is the one! He even has a spot to aim at just in the right spot! Ha ha

 

[havgunwilltravel]

I like the length on goat two, although goat one seems to be heavier but tapers pretty quick.

Have a great hunt and shoot either of the two that will give you the best memories, that's all that matters.

 

[What Map]

The one that gives you a clean shot first!

 

[Ron Wright]

Goat #1 seems to have a blockier nose and bigger head. He might be older.

 

[The Hedgehog]

This!

Goat #1 seems to have a blockier nose and bigger head. He might be older.

Might have to see them side by side to decide for certain, but this is what I'd choose based on.

 

[----]

That top goat could eat most the goats I've seen in my unit, what a pig.

 

[JCW]

He even has a spot to aim at just in the right spot! Ha ha

Great looking goats, both are shooters in my book.

This Far Side always made me laugh.

 

[huntbux]

I like the way goat #2 looks so I would go with him. Its a toss up whichever one you like better. Don't wont worry about which one is bigger, which one you like better? That is what would matter more to me.