2019-2020 elk

Elmacho · Dec 13, 2018

So, here we are again... almost draw time!

Since I am holding 12 points now, I am considering units 16 and 45. Should I be considering others? (Looking to have a GOOD shot at breaking 320)
I want to hunt archery during the rut!, maybe have a chance to come back with a rifle if needed.......

I need some help narrowing it down, pros and cons, so that I can scout this coming summer/fall and make a decision! I have heard 16 has property issues, but how bad is it, REALLY?

Thanks and Happy Holidays to All

Estimator86 · Dec 13, 2018

State?

Russp17 · Dec 13, 2018

I take it you are talking about wyoming?

45 is a type 9 or type 1 which means you cant do both. I would go towards 16.

mhungerford · Dec 13, 2018

16 does have property issues the Q creek owns most of what is not public. you can still find great elk on public.

LCH · Dec 13, 2018

Russp17 said:
I take it you are talking about wyoming?

45 is a type 9 or type 1 which means you cant do both. I would go towards 16.

False, he'd only lose the 1st half of September with a Type 1.

https://wgfd.wyo.gov/Regulations/Regulation-PDFs/REGULATIONS_CH7.pdf

Russp17 · Dec 13, 2018

LCH said:
False, he'd only lose the 1st half of September with a Type 1.

https://wgfd.wyo.gov/Regulations/Regulation-PDFs/REGULATIONS_CH7.pdf

Yep you are correct I looked at that wrong, I thought 45 was like 38, 39 and 40 where you can't hunt with a type 1 tag. 45 you can hunt sept 15-30th. Sorry for the false info.

Fremont15 · Dec 13, 2018

16-2 is your best bet for a giant. Watch Randy's latest video of the WY elk hunt with his son. With that tag you can archery hunt the rut and come back with a rifle in the late season if unsuccessful in September.

Jayden12 · Dec 14, 2018

Well, your 16-2 odds just went downhill

NoWiser · Dec 15, 2018

Yup. That just became a max point hunt.

jtm307 · Dec 15, 2018

Look on the bright side. Your choice is easy now. 45 it is.

Elmacho · Dec 15, 2018

Yes, looking at wyo. Thanks for the updates, can I delete this now, so as to keep my chances of drawing reasonable?

Dieseldog · Dec 16, 2018

Fremont15 said:
16-2 is your best bet for a giant. Watch Randy's latest video of the WY elk hunt with his son. With that tag you can archery hunt the rut and come back with a rifle in the late season if unsuccessful in September.

Serving up softballs

sneakem · Dec 16, 2018

Fremont15 said:
16-2 is your best bet for a giant. Watch Randy's latest video of the WY elk hunt with his son. With that tag you can archery hunt the rut and come back with a rifle in the late season if unsuccessful in September.

There are bulls like that in almost every general unit in Wyoming. There are also elk like that in 1,2,7,11,19,22,23,24,30,31,32,35,38,39,40,41,45,49,51,53,54,55,56,58,59,61,62,63,64,78,84,91,93,95,100,108,111,114,117,118,120,122,124.

Fact is most units you can bow hunt and then come back and rifle hunt....

Fact is that 4x more "Giant Bulls" come from Park County and the NW corner than any other part of the state, its just math....

Fact is you'll see 10 times more elk in 16 on private land that's off limits than on public.... Yes you could kill a great elk, you could also eat your tag. You could also write Stan Kroenke a check and kill an elk bigger than Matthew's, maybe smaller...

Funny that everyone chases the "unit", hoping to draw instead of drawing a tag, putting some effort in and killing a good animal. Randy has done well drawing less than desirable units throughout the west and harvesting some great animals. Why? Because he puts in the time researching, scouting, honing his craft, instead of chasing the "unit". That's what his show is about...Throw Buzz's first hand knowledge of that area on top of that it probably looks like a dream unit. Fact is 97% of people will hunt the same unit and not kill a bull like Matthew's. Good unit? Sure... but so are many of the rest...

TheDudeAbides · Dec 16, 2018

Jayden12 said:
Well, your 16-2 odds just went downhill

Like it really matters.

Gohunt has it as a 340 potential hunt.

Which means it is going to be on the radar for a lot of hunting journals. Eastman, HF, Epic, etc.

Elmacho · Dec 16, 2018

Thanks Sneakum,

Appreciate the insight, but maybe ease-up on the energy drinks.....Just because I have points stacked doesn't mean I am chasing a units for some mythical dream hunt.....
Been raising a family 1000 miles away, therefore points build up....Just doesn't make sense to go blow the whole wad on a 2-4 point unit when there may be a better opportunity this one time.

Thank you all who have contributed to my research before I continue scouting this year, and maybe next, to narrow down my two or three choices to one. I have spent a ton of time learning wyoming the last 5 years, its God's country for sure...

Elmacho · Dec 16, 2018

deleted duplicate

Fremont15 · Dec 17, 2018

Relax folks, there was nothing wrong with my post.

wannakillabigbull · Dec 18, 2018

Fremont15 said:
There was nothing wrong with my post.

Perhaps send the OP a PM next time if you want to give them that specific of info. Just a thought.

Fremont15 · Dec 18, 2018

Specifics are more helpful than the generic answers that really don’t help anybody.

2019-2020 elk

Active member

Active member

Member

Active member

Well-known member

Member

Active member

Member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Active member

Active member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Active member

Active member

Active member

Well-known member

Active member

Similar threads

Forum statistics

Share this page