Rank your meat

Poke 'Em · Feb 17, 2018

Based on what I've shot:

1. Whitetail Fawn (spots and all)
2. Pronghorn
3. Elk
4. Caribou
5. Whitetail adult
6. Black Bear (higher based on flavor, but the need to cook it to higher temps knocks it down the list)
7. Moose
8. Mule Deer

Poke 'Em · Feb 17, 2018

Poke 'Em said:
Based on what I've shot:

1. Whitetail Fawn (spots and all)
2. Pronghorn
3. Elk
4. Caribou
5. Black Bear (higher based on flavor, but the need to cook it to higher temps knocks it down the list)
6. Moose
7. Mule Deer

That was just for big game. If I add in all the game I've killed:

1. Fox Squirrel
2. Whitetail Fawn (spots and all)
3. Turkey
4. Pronghorn
5. Elk
6. Caribou
7. Rabbits
8. Hungarian Partridge
9. Sharp-tailed Grouse
10. Pheasant
11. Black Bear (higher based on flavor, but the need to cook it to higher temps knocks it down the list)
12. Moose
13. Ducks
14. Mule Deer
15. Swan
16. Canada Goose
17. Snow Goose

noharleyyet · Feb 17, 2018

In order or preference

Elk (burger)
Elk tenderloin
Elk rounds & strap
Beef
Smoked pork (domestic or feral)
Dove/quail (not store bought quail)
Local catfish, striped bass, crappie, sand bass
Shell seafood
Flying rib-eyes
Mountain trout....
Moose & axis are on my list to try

Smoked baloney (yea I know how it's made & still like it)

JLDemo · Feb 17, 2018

Elk
Antelope
Dove
Whitetail
Pheasant/Quail
Wild pig
Moose
Grouse
Squirrel
Rabbit
Duck/Goose
Mule Deer

Before I moved to Wyoming I used to travel to hunt elk, deer and antelope, now that I live here I travel even further to find dove and quail and higher numbers of pheasant! Never ate bear, but it's on my list to try.

noharleyyet: I'm right there with ya on the smoked baloney. I've got to pick what I want out first before the spawn get a hold of it. It doesn't last long.

sneakypete · Feb 17, 2018

Stone sheep back straps
Moose
Elk
Mule deer

onpoint · Feb 17, 2018

Antelope loins grilled in antelope camp.
Sizzling Sharptail, red pepper, and onion fajitas.
Nothing whatsoever made with duck.........

BrentD · Feb 17, 2018

onpoint said:
Antelope loins grilled in antelope camp.

So right you are!

Nothing whatsoever made with duck.........

Treat it like a good beef roast. Cook it to rare in a good sauce or marinade and you will change your tune.

onpoint · Feb 17, 2018

Then I will have a piece of rare marinaded duck tasting duck.
Besides, I can think of no more boring type of hunting than sitting in a hole/boat/field etc. on one's fat ass waiting for some birds to fly over

But that is a whole different thread altogether, and folks may need to disagree

Back to the meat!

idnative1948 · Feb 17, 2018

Pronghorn
Moose
Elk
Deer

Old Ranger · Feb 17, 2018

1.Eland
2.Eland
3.Eland
4.Cow Elk
5.Antelope

MTPUBLICLAND · Feb 17, 2018

Antelope has always been my favorite, but I was lucky enough to go on an alaska moose hunt this year and that is some great tasting steak. Still probably 1)antelope (2)moose (3)elk (4)whitetail (5)bear (6)mule deer

jvanhoy · Feb 17, 2018

Elk
Mule deer
Wild turkey breast
Whitetail
Black bear

N2TRKYS · Feb 17, 2018

1) whitetail
2) turkey
3) rabbit
4) duck
5) antelope
6) wild pig
7) elk
8) mule deer

bobbydean · Feb 17, 2018

Oryx
elk

mule deer young

mule deer old

Yoteoboth · Feb 17, 2018

That's just evil to a hungry man.

6mm Remington · Feb 17, 2018

1. Antelope
2. Elk
3. Mule deer
4. Black Bear
5. Bighorn Sheep
6. Cottontail Rabbit & Grouse & Pheasant
7. Mountain Lion
8. Moose
9. Whitetail deer

sschultz · Feb 17, 2018

I've ate just about everything mentioned from North America. But I gotta add cat ( Lynx and Mountain Lion ) I had some barbecued Lynx that was outstanding. And from what I hear there is no shortage of takers for Mountain Lion when one is taken.

onpoint · Feb 17, 2018

Just an fyi for you mountain lion eaters out there. Check out page 44 of this document.
1971-1989 in Montana, 899 lions tested for tric. 54% positive, from 15% in R5(Billings area) to 70.3% positive in R1 (Kalispell area).
Not being an alarmist whatsoever - just wonder how many out there know about this stuff. I Know folks who eat lion, not a one who came down "with the cramps real hard". Personally, I'll pass on the offer of the tasty lion jerky...............
Interesting info out there if you look for it..................

The link I tried to attach didn't work, but google "incidence of trichinosis in mountain lions" click on the MFWP final EIS document about 8 entries down the list......

CUElk · Feb 17, 2018

elk
wild hog
whitetail
muley

BrentD · Feb 17, 2018

Just had javelina for the first time tonight. I have to put between elk and whitetails. Damn good. A lot like warthog.

Rank your meat

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

New member

Well-known member

Active member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Similar threads

Forum statistics

Share this page