More Horses than Chukars

Hunting birds Sunday saw over 100 horses. This herd is near Dugway about 90 minutes southwest of Salt Lake. View attachment 77321

Serious issue that needs dealing with...ASAP. This is one of the worst problems facing our public lands and native wildlife......as a side question any luck on chukars...see or get any?
 
Your lucky you only saw 100. Funding for gathers is hard for the BLM to come by.

I'd look north of there for chukar...
 
Your lucky you only saw 100. Funding for gathers is hard for the BLM to come by.

I'd look north of there for chukar...

Probably one of those issues which will need to come to a head soon. One county in Utah threatened to roundup herds last year and hold for the BLM to come get.

Some birds. Need to work on my shooting. Thanks for the directional pointer. I'll trek that direction next trip.
 
Wow, I didn't realize this was an issue.

Really? Take a look at it. Very, very serious issue. Due to the closure of horse slaughter facilities people have been dumping horses on public lands. Massive numbers of animals. The BLM does their best, but are hamstrung by SJW and a well intentioned but unfunded law.

Horrible situation. My personal belief is that a season needs to be opened on them. Tags, rules, dates. Horse meat is considered food around the world, and should be here.
 
Probably one of those issues which will need to come to a head soon. One county in Utah threatened to roundup herds last year and hold for the BLM to come get.

Some birds. Need to work on my shooting. Thanks for the directional pointer. I'll trek that direction next trip.
Both the Wilderness and the other side of the interstate used to hold birds. Find some guzzlers and you'll be into birds. If you are up for the drive western Box Elder had a good number of birds.
 
Serious issue that needs dealing with...ASAP. This is one of the worst problems facing our public lands and native wildlife......as a side question any luck on chukars...see or get any?

So, you're in favor of eradication of all non-native species?
 
So, you're in favor of eradication of all non-native species?

That's an interesting question, given the OPs quarry is a non-native bid from the Himalayas. I really doubt there is a black and white answer to this question, and one must look holistically at the impacts the species has on its environment. I can easily argue a chukar has negligible impact on either 1) its habitat and 2) any native species that inhabit the same area. The same cannot be said for a wild/feral horse.
 
So, you're in favor of eradication of all non-native species?

When did I say that? Things like chukars, pheasants,etc. do not have the affect wild horses do and we all know it. When did I say eradicate wild horses? Let’s just bring them down to reasonable levels and at least to managment goals. I don’t support whiping out wild horses, but I do believe their numbers have to be significantly reduced and it’s something that has to happen at some point not just needs to. This is the argument of the horse advocates. No one is saying get rid of them all, let’s just bring them to sustainable levels where they aren’t damaging habitat and water sources for everything else, especially native wildlife. The damage wild horses do is getting to be pretty bad for a feral species we could control if not for wacko horse people. A species like chuckar that does nothing but make use of another out of control non-native (cheat grass) species is no where near a comparison to wild horses on the landscape.
 
Last edited:
When did I say that? Things like chukars, pheasants,etc. do not have the affect wild horses do and we all know it. When did I say eradicate wild horses? Let’s just bring them down to reasonable levels and at least to managment goals. I don’t support whiping out wild horses, but I do believe their numbers have to be significantly reduced and it’s something that has to happen at some point not just needs to. This is the argument of the horse advocates. No one is saying get rid of them all, let’s just bring them to sustainable levels where they aren’t damaging habitat and water sources for everything else, especially native wildlife. The damage wild horses do is getting to be pretty bad for a feral species we could control if not for wacko horse people. A species like chuckar that does nothing but make use of another out of control non-native (cheat grass) species is no where near a comparison to wild horses on the landscape.

I suggest you do some research on pheasants and their impacts on native grouse.
 
I suggest you do some research on pheasants and their impacts on native grouse.

I haven’t looked into it, but in a place like Utah pheasants and grouse are nowhere near each other for the most part so they haven’t had a negative impact as far as my surroundings. Maybe because there’s only about 10 wild pheasants left in Utah as well. I haven’t looked beyond Utah on t he affects pheasants May have elsewhere. Wild horses however affect deer, pronghorn, elk, and the landscape in general all around my state and the west.
 
Really? Pheasants vs. grouse is where you are at in this debate? That's not even reasonable.
 
living on the east coast the feral horse thing is a mind boggling dilemma and I"m sure it's only worse if you live WITH them:

east coast it would be very cut/dry: if there is a horse running around in the woods it would be captured and owner would be found or sent to a "rescue" as a horse is a domesticated animal

you guys in the west are sortof screwed as no one wants to step up to the plate and lay down an honest management plan. you are stuck with them being in that gray area of "feral" where the game department can't say "hey it's a wild critter living in the ecosystem that must be managed" (a hunt of some nature) but they are too scared of the crazies to offer BLM their help, BLM is trying to keep the game department, hunters, and crazies happy but spending a LOT of OUR money to do it... and to what result?

now I will say I have seen horse people say "we need to do something, a hunt is probably the most humane and cost effective means to population control" but to get more horse people on board with that theory and THEN get someone to just tell the city slicker horse lovers to shove it... too many barriers but hopefully someone will step up to the plate take the heat and lead the way
 
You think the horses are bad, you should see the number of wild burros we had in AZ. All protected under the same stupid law.
 
That's an interesting question, given the OPs quarry is a non-native bid from the Himalayas. I really doubt there is a black and white answer to this question, and one must look holistically at the impacts the species has on its environment. I can easily argue a chukar has negligible impact on either 1) its habitat and 2) any native species that inhabit the same area. The same cannot be said for a wild/feral horse.
The "native species" comment is what led me that direction.
When did I say that? Things like chukars, pheasants,etc. do not have the affect wild horses do and we all know it. When did I say eradicate wild horses? Let’s just bring them down to reasonable levels and at least to managment goals. I don’t support whiping out wild horses, but I do believe their numbers have to be significantly reduced and it’s something that has to happen at some point not just needs to. This is the argument of the horse advocates. No one is saying get rid of them all, let’s just bring them to sustainable levels where they aren’t damaging habitat and water sources for everything else, especially native wildlife. The damage wild horses do is getting to be pretty bad for a feral species we could control if not for wacko horse people. A species like chuckar that does nothing but make use of another out of control non-native (cheat grass) species is no where near a comparison to wild horses on the landscape.

Maybe eradication was to strong a word, but when you didn't specify the control level, it leads to my assumption of what I see most often as eradication. So, who defines reasonable levels? USFW? Private Bio's? State Legislature?
 

Forum statistics

Threads
110,814
Messages
1,935,402
Members
34,888
Latest member
Jack the bear
Back
Top