Spotter vs Scope

• Apr 4, 2012

• #1

B

barefooter19

Member

Joined

Jan 18, 2005

Messages

187

I need both but can only afford one. If you were going rifle elk hunting and thought you needed a new scope or a new spotting scope what one is more important ? I have a couple Leupolds 4x12x40 VX1 ok but not the best IMO .Would you buy the best scope you could or a good spotter? What brand and power ? Thanks.

 

• Apr 4, 2012

• #2

dainer

New member

Joined

May 24, 2011

Messages

316

Location

NE Nevada

IMO I would go with the spotter. You will spend 1000x the amount of time behind the spotter in comparison to the 30 seconds at 300 yards behind the scope. Not sure what your price range is, but I would buy the best glass you can afford....

 

• Apr 4, 2012

• #3

belly-deep

Active member

Joined

Oct 31, 2009

Messages

3,459

As long as you have not had any problems with the Leupold rifle scopes, I'd stick with them and buy a spotter

 

• Apr 4, 2012

• #4

Bambistew

Well-known member

Joined

Dec 10, 2002

Messages

7,616

Location

Chugiak, AK

I'd spend as much money as you can on a spotter. I haven't paid more than $200 for a scope, and doubt I ever will. In all my time hunting, I've yet to have a situation where I wished I had a 'better' scope. I think I have about half a dozen VX1's and a few older Vari X II. Pretty sure my spotter cost more than all of them combined. Seems like there are some great deals on spotters these days. The technology keeps getting better and prices keep dropping. Mid range scopes are better than the top end stuff of about 10 years ago it seems.

 

• Apr 4, 2012

• #5

Khunter

Well-known member

Joined

Jun 8, 2008

Messages

3,500

Location

western Colorado

Spotter unles you have some need to kill stuff from the next zip code over. If you like getting within reasonable proximity to what you kill, buy a great spotter that wil allow you to find and evaluate the critter.

As for brands, bracket them based on the cash your can spend, and then try them out.

 

• Apr 4, 2012

• #6

noharleyyet

Well-known member

Joined

Nov 15, 2004

Messages

41,272

Location

TEXAS

Bambi has it right. I have an older Vari X III 3/10/50...the new VX 2 3x9x40 sure seems as clear and eye relief as good...at under 300 bucks.

 

• Apr 5, 2012

• #7

MinnesotaHunter

Well-known member

Joined

Sep 15, 2010

Messages

4,288

Location

White Bear Lake, Minnesota

I agree with Bambi. I would add Binoculars to the top of my order of precedence for spending money on optics:

1. Binoculars (Leupold Mojave and Nikon Manarch 5)
2. Spotting Scope (Vortex Skyline)
3. Rifle Scope (Leupolds VX-II and III's)

My personal glassing style relies more heavily on my binos than my spotter. That being said I have yet to spend alot of money on any of them.

 

• Apr 5, 2012

• #8

B

barefooter19

Member

Joined

Jan 18, 2005

Messages

187

I have a good pair of binos. I guess I'll look at some spotters.

 

• Apr 6, 2012

• #9

C

Corax

Member

Joined

Jul 19, 2011

Messages

750

Location

Texas

IMO, Clear, sharp glass in a scope is a nice to have, but reliability - holding zero, reproducible changes in settings - is vital. If your zero on the VX-1 is not drifting, stick with it. However - before you go for the spotter, are your binoculars working for you?

 

• Apr 7, 2012

• #10

B

barefooter19

Member

Joined

Jan 18, 2005

Messages

187

Yes my binos are working good for me but when your looking at things a long ways off it's hard to tell how the animal really looks. I've never owned a spotting scope so I was thinking a spotter would help me there to really see the detail. ????? The scope works good and I'm not really wanting to shoot over 300 - 350 yards so my scopes will probably do the job ok .

 

• Sep 26, 2012

• #11

D

DIY HUNTER

Member

Joined

Sep 14, 2012

Messages

48

As long as you are fine with the clarity,light gathering ability, etc. of your scope then I would try to get the spotter. I would try to get a higher end one if I could though, some of the low end ones aren't much better than a good set of binoculars.

 

• Sep 26, 2012

• #12

bigeasygator

New member

Joined

Mar 1, 2012

Messages

260

Location

New Orleans, LA

I don't think I can answer this question without more information. Where will you be hunting? What style will the hunting be (backpack, horseback, dayhunting, etc)? What's the terrain like? How long is the typical shot? How far off do you think you'd be able to glass an animal?

If both tools were vital to where you hunt and you had to pick one, I'd probably go with the spotter. I've been places where a spotting scope wouldn't do you a lick of good (hell, I've left the binoculars at home in some places because it's so thick). If you were going to spend most of your day behind glass, definitely add a nice spotting scope to the mix. If your style is a little more "running and gunning" so to speak, I'd leave it at home.